A major transparency fight is brewing in New Jersey and it could have serious implications for how gun permit data is handled moving forward.
The Citizens Committee for the Right to Keep and Bear Arms (CCRKBA) announced that board member and journalist John Petrolino has filed a lawsuit against New Jersey officials after repeated denials of public records requests tied to the state’s carry permit system.
While CCRKBA is not a named party in the case, the organization is publicly backing Petrolino’s effort, framing it as a broader fight for transparency in a state long criticized for restrictive gun laws.
The roots of the lawsuit go back to Petrolino’s 2024 reporting on New Jersey’s permit-to-carry system, where he uncovered a troubling trend: Black applicants were reportedly denied permits at more than double the rate of white applicants for non-criminal, subjective reasons.
Looking to expand on that reporting, Petrolino submitted records requests seeking data on retired law enforcement carry permits, specifically to compare how those applicants are treated versus the general public.
According to the complaint, those requests were repeatedly denied.
The lawsuit argues that both Petrolino and the public have a “strong interest” in understanding how carry permits are issued across different demographics, including race, sex, location, and appeal outcomes. It also raises a key question: whether retired law enforcement applicants are subject to the same scrutiny or something entirely different.
Petrolino says the resistance from the New Jersey State Police has been consistent and deliberate.
“The NJSP has denied countless records requests that I’ve made over the years, never fulfilling even one,” he said. “When I emailed them about these denials, an unnamed person at NJSP basically told me to sue them, so here we are.”
The legal filing claims those denials violate his common law right of access as well as the New Jersey Civil Rights Act, and seeks injunctive relief forcing the state to turn over the requested records.
CCRKBA Chairman Alan Gottlieb didn’t hold back in his support.
“Records concerning the retired police officer permits are about as public as you can get,” Gottlieb said. “Do they have the same level of perceived bias in their permitting statistics? Or perhaps worse yet, do they not? The public has a right to know this information.”
The case, Petrolino v. New Jersey State Police, was filed in New Jersey Superior Court in Mercer County on February 27, 2026, and is expected to draw significant attention as it moves forward.
At its core, this isn’t just about one journalist or one set of records. It’s about whether the public can access data that could reveal how fairly (or unfairly) a fundamental constitutional right is being administered.
If Petrolino wins, it could force New Jersey to open the books in a way it’s resisted for years.
And if he doesn’t, it raises an even bigger question: what exactly is the state trying to hide?
*** Buy and Sell on GunsAmerica! ***
Read the full article here
