Guns

What Started the Confrontation Decides Who Walks Free

November 17, 2026

Two armed citizens fired the fatal shot in self-defense cases last fall, but only one walked away without a legal cloud hanging over him — and the difference came down to who started the confrontation, according to Cam Edwards at Bearing Arms.

Snapshot

In Detroit, a carjacking victim shot two suspects, killing one, after being forced to his knees and hearing an order to shoot him and another victim. In St. Louis, prosecutors declined to charge a driver who shot and killed 59-year-old Vance Townes following a road-rage incident, concluding the legal case for self-defense couldn't be overcome.

Key points

  • Clear threat, clear outcome: Detroit police said two suspects forced victims from a Hyundai Elantra at gunpoint; one victim drew his own gun and fired after hearing a command to shoot them.
  • Messier facts, same legal result: Police said Townes honked and yelled at a slow-moving Honda driver before both pulled into a parking lot; surveillance video showed the Honda driver going the wrong way into the lot where Townes had stopped.
  • Armed approach changed everything: Police said Townes walked toward the Honda holding a handgun, and the driver, with his family inside, fired five shots from the car.
  • Legal expert weighs in: Attorney Jay Kanzler said a driver approached by an armed person has a clear right to shoot under state law, and that prosecutors were right not to file charges.
  • Bad judgment isn't the same as losing the right to self-defense: Edwards argues the Honda driver arguably shouldn't have followed Townes into the lot, but that decision didn't erase his right to protect his family once Townes approached armed.

Quick take

Edwards's larger point is that owning a gun doesn't settle a self-defense case on its own — how the confrontation started and escalated does. The Detroit case looks like a textbook justified shooting; the Missouri case shows that even when a citizen makes a questionable choice, prosecutors can still find the shooting legally sound once the other party introduces a weapon and closes the distance.

Read the full story: bearingarms.com

Privacy Policy  ·  Terms  ·  Contact