Guns

Supreme Court Leaves Mixed Maryland Gun-Zone Ruling Intact

November 16, 2026

The Supreme Court declined to hear Novotny v. Moore on Monday, leaving in place a Fourth Circuit ruling that upholds most of Maryland's "sensitive places" gun restrictions, according to Bearing Arms.

Snapshot

The underlying case challenged Maryland's post-Bruen expansion of gun-free zones, with the Fourth Circuit upholding bans in museums and certain state-controlled buildings while finding restrictions on parks, forests, and entertainment venues constitutionally shaky. By denying cert, the Supreme Court leaves that mixed outcome standing for now.

Key points

  • Cert denied: The Supreme Court turned away Maryland's "sensitive places" challenge, keeping the Fourth Circuit's ruling in effect, Bearing Arms reports.
  • Thomas writes separately: Justice Clarence Thomas said he doubts every Maryland statute fits "this Nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation" in sensitive places, but agreed cert should wait for a narrower case.
  • Broader pattern cited: Thomas noted other states have stretched "sensitive places" far beyond legislatures, polling places, or courthouses, pointing to New Jersey's roughly 25 restricted locations, New York's 20, and California's 29.
  • Possible next vehicle: Bearing Arms columnist Cam Edwards flags Christian v. James, a pending challenge to New York's park carry ban, with New York's response due December 3, as a case that could draw the Court's interest.
  • Related denial: The Court also denied cert in Colie v. Commonwealth of Virginia, leaving intact a conviction on a single unlawful discharge charge for a concealed carry holder otherwise acquitted in a self-defense shooting.

Quick take

Edwards argues the piecemeal approach is frustrating precisely because Thomas himself recognizes how broadly states have redefined "sensitive," yet the Court keeps passing on cases that could clarify the issue at scale. For armed citizens navigating a patchwork of state rules, that means more years of uncertainty before the high court tackles the bigger question directly.

Read the full story: bearingarms.com

Privacy Policy  ·  Terms  ·  Contact