Sixth Circuit Upholds Federal Gun Ban for Mentally Ill Under Bruen
A federal appeals court has upheld the law that strips gun rights from people found to be dangerously mentally ill, ruling that the prohibition survives the Second Amendment framework set out in Bruen.
Snapshot
On October 29, 2026, a Sixth Circuit panel rejected a facial challenge to 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(4), the federal law barring firearm possession by anyone adjudicated "a mental defective" or committed to a mental institution. The ruling came in the case of Alexander Laykovich, who was convicted after being found with eight firearms, ammunition, knives and drugs near Fort Knox, Kentucky, roughly a year after a Missouri court had ordered him detained and barred him from possessing guns.
Key points
- The ruling: Judge Eric Murphy, joined by Judges Gibbons and Hermandorfer, held the law constitutional, with the government conceding Laykovich remained part of "the people" protected by the Second Amendment.
- The history test: Under Bruen's second step, the court found longstanding historical practice of confining dangerous mentally ill individuals a close enough analogue to justify disarmament.
- The backstory: A Missouri court had detained Laykovich for 21 days in 2023 and ruled him "incompetent" to carry under state law; he never petitioned to have that ban lifted.
- The arrest: Kentucky officers found body armor, a body cam, eight firearms, ammunition, knives, a gas can, marijuana and fentanyl in his vehicle after a traffic stop in January 2024.
- Unresolved question: The court itself noted that federal law never defines what mental illness qualifies for disarmament, from schizophrenia to ADHD, but didn't have to resolve that ambiguity here.
Quick take
Tom Knighton of Bearing Arms says he's torn: the Second Amendment protects "the people" broadly, yet society has long restricted the liberty of those judged dangerously ill. He argues the law still needs a clear, consistent standard for what counts as "adjudicated," rather than vague hospitalization rules, and suspects this particular case is a weak vehicle for pushing that fight further up the courts.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com