When I got orders to Fort Sill, Oklahoma, as a young 2nd Lieutenant right out of flight training I thought there had been a mistake. At least I hoped that was the case. I couldn’t find anybody in the Aviation community who had ever been there. I checked with the little old lady in tennis shoes who managed such stuff. She verified that I was indeed doomed.

Turning Lemons into Lemonade

Fort Sill is the home of the Field Artillery. It also turned out to be the coolest first operational assignment for which an Aviation Lieutenant might hope. For a time, I was the only Company-grade officer on post in a flight suit. That gave me credibility. Colonels and Generals who might otherwise not have scraped their boots on me were sincerely interested in my opinions. I got to fly UH-1H, OH-58A, and CH-47D aircraft while there. Lawton was good for my family as well. I worked hard, but it was a great time.

One of the best-kept secrets thereabouts is the Ouachita Mountains Wildlife Refuge. Comprising some 60,000 acres of rugged granite mountains, sweeping prairies, and freshwater lakes adjacent to Fort Sill to the north, the wildlife refuge was mesmerizing. I’ve traveled the world, and there were some geological formations in the Ouachita Mountains that were unlike anything I have ever encountered elsewhere.

Baker Peak – Hidden Treasure

22,400 of those 60,000 acres are open to the public. The rest is fenced into a Special Use Area reserved solely for wildlife. On rare occasions, the local Park Rangers will take a busload of enthusiasts behind the fence to listen to the elk bugle. You have to arrange this well in advance, and it doesn’t happen very often. My wife and I were fortunate enough to pull it off.

Tucked away in Comanche County, Oklahoma, deep inside the Special Use Area is a modest rocky feature called Baker Peak. This 2,395-foot mountain is south of Cutthroat Lake and west of Grace Mountain. It juts up otherwise forgotten and lonely from the surrounding desolate terrain.

The Park Rangers that day related a most fantastic tale concerning how this forlorn rock got its name. After decades of searching, the only decent Internet reference I can find is a brief but professionally produced YouTube video by a local history enthusiast. It has only 504 views at the time of this writing. The story in the video loosely parallels that told by the Rangers.

Private Baker

The story goes that Private Baker was an Army scout during the Indian Wars. The YouTube video claimed he was out scouting solo for Brigadier General Matthew Arbuckle. That would have set this fight in the 1830s. If I recall correctly, the Rangers’ version of the tale had Baker out with a comrade in the service of Custer’s Seventh Cavalry. That would have made it 1869. The site of Custer’s winter bivouac was right down the street from our house on post. Considering how dangerous this place was at that time it strains credulity that a uniformed member of the Army would be out scouting alone, so I tend to subscribe to the Park Rangers’ version.

Baker and his buddy purportedly got separated from the main body of troops and found themselves suddenly pursued by a hostile Indian war party. The video alleged that these were likely Kiowas. According to the Rangers, both soldiers were on horseback, and they also had a mule burdened with a case of ammunition for their rifles. Unable to get back to their parent command, they retreated to what would be known as Baker Peak, the most prominent high ground in the immediate area.

Things Get Real

By now the Indians were close, and the soldiers’ mounts fell to hostile fire. Baker and his buddy had just enough time to salvage the spare ammo and scramble to the top of the peak before they were surrounded. Now with Indians all around, the two Army scouts fortified their position as best they could.

Baker Peak makes for a superb defensive redoubt. There is only one reasonable approach, and that is through a deep rocky defile. These are old mountains, and most of the ravines and valleys are characterized by massive rivers of boulders. 

Tactical Details

The legend went that Baker’s buddy was hit and killed in short order, leaving PVT Baker alone and cut off on this bleak mountaintop. There he remained for three long days and nights, avoiding sleep for fear of Indians infiltrating to kill him. He was also purportedly without food or water.

The story went that PVT Baker was surrounded by an Indian war party some seventy strong. I have no idea how they arrived at that number. Each time the Indians drew close he would repel them with rifle fire. The attacking Indians supposedly showered the hilltop with both arrows and bullets but were unable to reach Baker hunkered down as he was among the rocks.

Eventually, an Army officer perched upon an adjacent hilltop noticed a wisp of smoke coming from the distant peak and dispatched an armed patrol. The arrival of the Cavalrymen took the fight out of the Indians who retreated in good order. Baker was rescued, his buddy’s body recovered, and the patrol returned to the 7^th Cav laager.

The Weapons of the Baker Peak Legend

If the YouTube version of this tale is accurate, PVT Baker would likely have been armed with a flintlock musket akin to the 1835 Springfield. This .69-caliber weapon was loaded from the muzzle via paper cartridges and weighed around ten pounds. Though these weapons could fire buck and ball loads, the most common rounds fired a single lead ball. These lead balls were intentionally left slightly undersized to accommodate the inevitable powder fouling.

The effective range of the 1835 Springfield was listed as between 100 and 200 yards, though fifty yards was likely more realistic due to its smoothbore design. A determined operator could be expected to get off two to three rounds per minute of aimed fire. The 1842 Springfield was the same weapon fitted with a percussion lock.

Well, Probably not…

Defending yourself alone on a barren hilltop against 70 hostile Indians while armed with a flintlock musket is, I suppose, theoretically possible. However, it is practically improbable. Even if the terrain canalized the attackers up a single gully, I have to think these Indians could have eventually gotten to PVT Baker under those circumstances. That is another piece of the puzzle that leads me to think this exchange likely occurred after the Civil War.

If this fight took place around 1869 then PVT Baker likely carried some sort of Civil War-surplus weapon. US Cavalry troopers were liberally equipped with Spencer repeaters during this time. Additionally, there were large numbers of First and Second Allin breechloading conversions of the Springfield family of rifled muskets. The definitive Trapdoor Springfield did not see service until 1873. The falling-block Sharps was also in common use at the time.

Load on Sunday and Shoot All Week…

The Spencer repeater was designed in 1860 by Christopher Spencer and was the first military repeating rifle to fire metallic cartridges. The definitive Spencer carbine fed via a seven-round tubular magazine in the buttstock. While the Spencer’s lever action system did feed fresh rounds into the action, the hammer had to be manually cocked for each round fired. 

Compared to the muzzleloaders of the day, the Spencer really did offer a substantial enhancement in firepower. Around 200,000 copies rolled off the lines before production ceased in 1869. The Spencer offered a practical rate of fire of between 14 and 20 rounds per minute.

Springfield Upgrades

Breechloading conversions of Springfield rifles typically involved machining off the near end of the barrel and replacing that portion with a pivoting chamber assembly that accepted a metallic cartridge. Early conversions included a barrel liner that sleeved the barrel down from .58 to .50 caliber, but these liners tended to loosen over time. The Model 1868 included a new-made .50-caliber barrel that resolved this problem. Roughly 50,000 copies were made chambered in .50-70 Government.

The Sharps rifle action was first patented in 1848 and saw regular improvements throughout the Civil War. The definitive cavalry model used during the Indian Wars was chambered in .50-70 Government and weighed 9.5 pounds. This single-shot weapon fed metallic cartridges and offered between 8 and 10 rounds per minute.

Question Everything

The Internet revolutionized the way we manage information. While the Information Superhighway grants me instant access to historical details I use every week to flesh out these stories, it also grants anyone with a keyboard a voice. That results in a great deal of misinformation and outright lies. The discriminating reader should approach stories like these with skepticism.

READ MORE: Dr Dabbs – The Battle for the La Fière Bridge: “I Know of No Better Spot to Die”

In this case, the terrain feature was indeed named after an Army soldier named Baker. The Park Rangers who related the tale to me seemed certain of its veracity. I choose to believe it myself.

Ruminations On the Baker Peak Legend

Certain places embody a profound gravitas based upon some deeply poignant event. The Airborne and Ranger Schools at Fort Benning have seen their share of pain as has BUD/S where baby SEALs are born at Coronado in San Diego. I have been to all three of those places in various official capacities and found the experience to be undeniably moving. I was also struck speechless when I placed my hand in the hole that held the cross of Christ. Some places are just bigger than humanity.

In the story of PVT Baker, we see embodied such unimaginably powerful emotions that are now all but forgotten. Baker fought for his very life for three days not knowing if help was coming or not. Failure would have meant horrible torture and death at the hands of ruthless captors. With the benefit of hindsight, I hope the rest of his life was long, warm, and peaceful.

*** Buy and Sell on GunsAmerica! All Local Sales are FREE! ***