HomeGunsQ&A: How an Illinois Legal Case Can Help the Gun Cause in...

Q&A: How an Illinois Legal Case Can Help the Gun Cause in California

Published on

Weekly Newsletter

To be updated with all the latest news, offers and special announcements.

Last week’s ruling in in FFL-IL v. Pritzker represented a significant victory for a 2A community that has fought hard over decades to protect one of the Constitution’s most fundamental rights. The ruling overturned the state’s bans on so-called “assault weapons” and on standard capacity magazines.  

Bans like those imposed by Illinois, and cases challenging them, will sound familiar to California gun owners. Through cases like Duncan v. BontaRhode v. BontaBoland v. Bonta and other, the California Rifle & Pistol Association (CRPA) fights onerous restrictions imposed by a governor and legislature hell-bent on gun control. 

With so many cases churning along in so many circuits, CRPA President & General Counsel Chuck Michel sat in for a quick Q&A about this latest development and what comes next.

Q: What is the significance of the ruling in the Illinois case(s)?
A: Up until now, most “assault weapon” rulings across the country have been preliminary injunctions, and the Supreme Court tends to prefer to rule on final judgments. Well, we now have a final judgment in our challenge to Illinois’s ban on common rifles, and one with a very dense evidentiary record at that. Should the Supreme Court decide to not grant review in another pending case right now, it would make this case a strong contender for Supreme Court review if the Seventh Circuit does not see things our way with the upcoming appeal.

Q: What impact might that have on cases pending in California?
A: It is nice persuasive authority to be able to cite a district court judgment with such an extensive record, but it is still just a district court ruling. However, suppose we get a favorable ruling in the Seventh Circuit. In that case, that is strong persuasive authority for California cases, as appeals courts do consider the rulings of other appeals courts to an extent. And of course, should the Supreme Court ever take up the case, it is binding on everyone.

Q:  Could the Supreme Court be the next step?
A:  Well, the Seventh Circuit is the next step, but it’s certainly possible after that. Right now, the Supreme Court is considering a 4th Circuit case also on final judgment appeal called Snope v. Brown, which deals with Maryland’s ban on “assault weapons”. We’ll know in the next few months if the Supreme Court will grant review. Even if they do, however, Snope does not involve a magazine capacity challenge, nor does it deal with a registration requirement. Our case also covers those issues. We are hopeful the Supreme Court will grant Snope and settle at least one of the questions in our case, and then grant cert in our case to decide the remainder.

Q:  If so, how do you handicap the Court’s next choice for a 2A case?
A:  As stated, Snope is the biggest contender simply because it is already there. But if the Supreme Court decides “assault weapons” are too controversial an issue, it could decide to take another case in the “hardware” genre, such as our case of Duncan v. Bonta, which deals with California’s ban on magazines with a capacity of over ten rounds. It could also consider a handgun case like our Boland v. Bonta matter, which is about California’s various requirements on handguns that function essentially as a ban on most models.

—Article courtesy of CRPA

Read the full article here

Latest articles

Is .357 Magnum Good For Self-Defense?

The .357 Magnum has earned a legendary reputation in the...

Buy Green Get Green: RCBS Launches Rebate

Oroville, CA – America’s...

SAF Challenges Hawaii’s Gun Ban for Young Adults

The Second Amendment Foundation (SAF) is taking Hawaii to court...

Pittsburgh Finally Getting the Message on Preemption

In the wake of the shooting...

6 Best NEW Budget Hunting Rifles You can Buy Right Now [2025]

Watch full video on YouTube

More like this

New York bill would let police ‘briefly seize’ firearms during domestics

Police in New York want the legal ability to seize...

Free Range Kids | This one upset me

Download and start your preparedness journey now! My Patreon ... Watch full video on...

Mutilation, Torture, and Victory: A Soldier’s Fight for Life!

Watch full video on YouTube

Nanci Pelosi Blames God, Guns, & Gays On Trump Victory

Watch full video on YouTube