NJ Town's Citywide Gun Shop Ban Heads to December Hearing
A New Jersey town council has advanced an ordinance that would ban firearms shops outright in every zoning district, a move that goes well beyond the usual practice of pushing gun stores into industrial corners and instead tries to keep them out of the city altogether.
Snapshot
Summit's Common Council voted 5-1 to advance a measure that would prohibit any business that sells, rents, deals in or transfers firearms, while still allowing stores that sell only accessories like scopes and lights. According to Bearing Arms, Summit currently has no gun shops at all, and the council wants to keep it that way through a zoning change rather than wait for an application to test the issue.
Key points
- Full ban, not relocation: Unlike zoning laws in places like Newton, Massachusetts, or Goleta, California, that confine gun stores to certain areas, Summit's proposal would bar them from every district in town.
- Council's rationale: Councilman Dan Crisafulli said firearms shops pose unique risks to "neighborhood character, public safety, security, and theft," and argued the ordinance doesn't touch residents' right to own guns.
- Dissenting vote: Councilman Andrew Smith, an attorney and the lone no vote, warned the ban could be challenged as a Second Amendment violation and expose the city to costly litigation.
- Legal backdrop: Bearing Arms notes Third Circuit precedent has called a categorical ban on commercial firearm sales "untenable" under Heller, and under Bruen, Summit would need to show historical tradition supporting such a ban.
- Next step: The ordinance was introduced for public review, with a hearing set for December 1 before any final vote.
Quick take
This isn't a routine zoning tweak. A town trying to wall off an entire category of lawful commerce tied to a constitutional right is the kind of ordinance that tends to end up in federal court, especially given recent rulings against New Jersey gun restrictions.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com