USA

Wisconsin Homeowner, 75, Shoots Intruder Who Tried to Force Entry

November 18, 2026

A 75-year-old Wisconsin homeowner shot and killed a 35-year-old man who authorities say tried to force his way through the front door early Sunday morning, in an encounter that began with a separate break-in next door.

Snapshot

According to Bearing Arms, the incident unfolded in Oneida County around 1 a.m. on November 15 after James Roath, 35, first entered an elderly neighbor's home uninvited before being pushed outside. Roath then allegedly moved to Marshall Robinson's house, pounding on the siding and front door until Robinson, 75, answered armed and was grabbed by the glasses as Roath tried to push inside.

Key points

  • First contact: Authorities said Roath showed up at a neighboring woman's home around 1 a.m., got inside before she forced him back out and locked the door, and allegedly pounded and kicked at it before leaving.
  • Possible intoxication: The resident told police Roath appeared to be intoxicated, according to Bearing Arms' account of the incident.
  • Confrontation at Robinson's home: Robinson armed himself, opened the door to ask who was there, and fired after Roath allegedly grabbed his glasses and tried to shove past him into the house.
  • Outcome: Deputies and medical personnel responded and attempted lifesaving measures, but Roath was pronounced dead at the scene.
  • Investigation: The Oneida County Sheriff's Office is continuing to investigate the shooting.

Quick take

Bearing Arms' Cam Edwards argues Wisconsin's self-defense law creates a presumption that deadly force is justified when someone is unlawfully and forcibly entering a home, and he contends that presumption applies here given Roath's attempt to push past Robinson. Edwards also notes that at 75, Robinson had little reason to risk a physical struggle with a much younger intruder and every reason to defend himself once the stranger grabbed at him in the doorway.

Read the full story: bearingarms.com

Privacy Policy  ·  Terms  ·  Contact