Guns

Maryland rule lets armed worshippers drive but not walk to synagogue

November 19, 2026

A Maryland gun control rule tied to a local judge's September ruling lets licensed congregants drive to synagogue armed, but fines them for carrying the same firearm if they walk there instead, according to a report by the Forward.

Snapshot

The conflict centers on Rabbi Menashe Shapiro, a 29-year-old ordained rabbi and Georgetown University law student who serves on the volunteer armed security team at the Silver Spring Jewish Center. Because the synagogue can't staff a hired guard around the clock, trained and licensed congregants like Shapiro fill the gap, but a quirk in the local law's carry zone around houses of worship effectively blocks observant Jews from exercising that same right on Shabbat.

Key points

  • The loophole: Licensed owners may carry within 100 yards of the synagogue if they drive, but face a civil fine, $500 for a first offense and $750 after that, if they carry while walking, per the Forward's reporting.
  • Shabbat conflict: Orthodox Jews generally don't drive on Shabbat, so the driving exception is unusable for congregants who must walk to services, even within an eruv that otherwise permits carrying certain items.
  • Legal argument: Eric Baxter of Becket, representing the synagogue, told the Forward the rule serves no real safety purpose if it bars the very people who have to walk to get there.
  • Inside vs. outside: Shapiro can legally carry inside the synagogue under the ruling but can't legally carry on the route to reach it, a gap Bearing Arms' Tom Knighton called "beyond stupid."

Quick take

Knighton argues the rule shows how a facially neutral gun law can still land unevenly on a specific religious practice, since a non-congregant could carry up to the building's edge while a member who must walk on Shabbat cannot. For armed congregants who rely on volunteer security to protect their own services, the practical effect is the same no matter who's right about the legal theory.

Read the full story: bearingarms.com

Privacy Policy  ·  Terms  ·  Contact