USA

Fifth Circuit Says Second Amendment Covers Gun Sales, Not Just Ownership

November 20, 2026

A federal appeals court just handed gun owners a significant win, ruling that the Second Amendment doesn't stop at owning a firearm — it covers the right to buy and sell one, too.

Snapshot

The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in U.S. v. Deare that the Second Amendment's plain text protects commercial firearm sales, not just possession. A three-judge panel reversed a lower court's denial of defendant Jeremiah Deare's motion to dismiss federal dealing-without-a-license charges, sending the case back for further review, according to Bearing Arms.

Key points

  • Core holding: The panel found that the right to keep and bear arms necessarily includes the right to acquire them, meaning laws restricting firearm sales burden the constitutional rights of both buyers and sellers.
  • Government's burden unmet: According to Bearing Arms, the court concluded the government failed to show a historical tradition sufficiently comparable to the restriction at issue, a key requirement under current Second Amendment analysis.
  • Dissent and response: Judge Catharina Jacoba Hendrika Dubbelday Hayne dissented, arguing sellers aren't mentioned in the Second Amendment's text. Judge James Ho countered that by that logic, booksellers wouldn't be covered by the First Amendment either, calling that outcome untenable.
  • Narrowing Peterson: Judge Andrew Oldham's concurrence instructed the district court to disregard the Fifth Circuit's earlier Peterson decision on shall-issue licensing, arguing it had been stretched well beyond what Bruen's footnote nine actually supports.
  • Not over yet: The ruling doesn't clear Deare of the charges outright; the case returns to the district court for further proceedings.

Quick take

This ruling matters beyond one defendant's case. If the reasoning holds up, it puts real limits on how far states and the federal government can go in regulating gun sales and dealers, including rules that make it harder to buy handguns across state lines. Worth watching as other circuits weigh in.

Read the full story: bearingarms.com

Privacy Policy  ·  Terms  ·  Contact