Fiction’s worst commanders show that rank doesn’t earn trust
Military.com rounded up seven of the worst fictional military commanders from film, television and video games, a list timed to the 2026 Broadway revival of A Few Good Men.
Snapshot
The piece profiles officers whose failures range from abuse of authority to simple incompetence, pulling examples from Aliens, Battlestar Galactica, Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2, Apocalypse Now, M*A*S*H and The Caine Mutiny. Each entry breaks down the specific leadership problem the character represents, according to Military.com.
Key points
- Abuse of power: Col. Nathan Jessep in A Few Good Men orders an illegal Code Red that leads to a Marine's death, convinced his authority puts him above question, the outlet notes.
- Inexperience under fire: Lt. Scott Gorman in Aliens has logged dozens of simulated drops but only his second real one, and his indecision leaves his Marines exposed, per Military.com.
- Success without limits: Adm. Helena Cain in Battlestar Galactica keeps her ship fighting but does it through forced conscription, stripped refugee ships and executed subordinates.
- Betrayal for ambition: Gen. Shepherd in Modern Warfare 2 kills his own Task Force 141 operators to protect his reputation, the article recounts.
- Eroded trust: Lt. Cmdr. Philip Francis Queeg in The Caine Mutiny spirals into suspicion and erratic calls until his crew no longer believes he can safely command the ship.
Quick take
The throughline across all seven is simple: rank alone doesn't earn trust. Whether the failure is Lt. Col. Bill Kilgore's combat-as-recreation mindset in Apocalypse Now or Maj. Frank Burns turning the 4077th into a daily headache in M*A*S*H, Military.com's list is a reminder that fiction's worst commanders fail their troops long before the mission does.
Read the full story: military.com